Continental collision a driving force

Abstraction: The hit of India and Asia is widely considered to hold occurred during the early to stop Eocene, elating the 2.5 million km2 Tibetan Plateau. During the Cenozoic, markedly get downing at the Eocene-Oligocene Transition, a lessening in d18O of ice-cores and the addition in seawater 87Sr/86Sr points to a period of accelerated planetary climatic chilling concurrent with enduring in the Himalaya. The land mass has caused disturbances in atmospheric and pelagic circulation and seen the development of the Asiatic monsoon but their planetary impact is minimum. The chemical weathering of silicate stone over the Cenozoic has drawn-down CO2 from the ambiance from c. 1400ppmV to c. 200ppmV. This chemical weathering is greatest on inclines where intense orographic rainfall and mechanical weathering procedures are greatest. The CO2 degree has stabilized above 180ppmV since the Miocene despite the conditions for silicate weathering persisting. A negative feedback mechanism has been invoked where woods have been starved of CO2 and are replaced by grasslands, cut downing the usual capacity of flora to heighten silicate weathering by mechanical root action and acidifying of dirts. The palaeoclimatic informations suggest tableland upheaval ( and Continental hit ) occurred later than antecedently recognized, at c. 35 Ma.

Continental hit occurs when two ( or more ) Continental lithospheric home bases converge to the point of impact. A good established and typical consequence of Continental hit is thrust geological fault and orogenic upheaval, typically with initial significant topographic alleviation. Elevations of over 4,000 m in the present twenty-four hours can be seen in the active collisional systems of cardinal Japan, Taiwan and Papua New Guinea ( Aitchison et al. 2007 ) .

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The Himalayas represent the universe ‘s highest orogenic belt, formed during the Indo-Asia hit. There is a broad runing position on at what indicate difficult continent-continent hit took topographic point, with estimations between early and stop Eocene ( Aitchison et al. 2007 ; Hall et al. 2008 ; Rowley 1996 ) . The upheaval of the Himalayas formed the Tibetan Plateau, the largest individual topographic characteristic on the Earth ‘s surface, with an country over 2.5 million km2 at a average lift of over 5,000 m ( Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ; Harris 2006 ) .

In the early 1990s, Maureen Raymo and co-workers ( Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ; Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) suggested that the collision-derived upheaval of tableland and mountain scopes could hold altered regional and planetary clime through assorted chemical and mechanical procedures during Cenozoic Era.

These procedures are suggested to be either ( 1 ) direct physical impacts on the environment such as break in ocean and atmosphere circulation and ( 2 ) indirect geochemical effects changing degrees of atmospheric CO2 ( Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) .

The Cenozoic Era is a stage of long-run chilling marked by the Eocene-Oligocene passage ( EOT ) which saw the oncoming of the first ice-age, with the first ice-caps forming over Antarctica and aridification in the Himalaya country ( Dupont-Nivet et al. 2007 ) .

The direct climatic alterations come about by the physical presence of a big land mass such as the Himalya tableland. The planetal oversight rate ( 6.5oC/km ) causes elevated tableland to be much ice chest, particularly in the snow-clad winter where an albedo-temperature feedback develops. Extensive surface chilling could impact regional circulation with possible planetary climatic deductions. The high height land mass enhances orographic rainfall on the windward side of the mountains, and rainshadow drying on their downwind side ( Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) .

The formation of Tibetan Plateau has been extensively linked to the formation and consecutive development of the South Asiatic Monsoon ( Clift et al. 2008 ; Harris 2006 ; Dupont-Nivet et Al. 2007 ) . The summer monsoon is caused by warming of the land surface by the Sun, lifting of the het air, and a compensating influx of damp air from the ocean, with heavy rains and intense release of latent heat. ( Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) . Assorted workers have studied the yoke of the Himalayan disinterment rates and monsoon strength through clip. Evidence for the late Miocene strengthening of the Indian monsoon ( 6-8 Ma ) has been linked to tectonic activity in southern Tibet and Pliocene strengthening of the East Asiatic monsoon ( 2.6-3.6 Ma ) has been associated with upheaval of the northern tableland ( Clift et al. 2008, and mentions in this ) . These “physical” effects on the clime are non to the full understood beyond their regional context and are non thought to be globally influential ( Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) .

Raymo & A ; Ruddiman ‘s ( 1992 ) chief factor in “forcing” of the Cenozoic clime is the biogeochemical procedure of enhanced drawdown of atmospheric CO2 by the weathering of silicate stones. CO2 in the atmosphere reacts with groundwater to organize carbonaceous acid ( H2CO3 ) , which attacks silicate stones by hydrolysis. The reactions can be simplified to:

1 ) COA­2 + CaSiO3 CaCO3 + SiO2 ( after Allen & A ; Armstrong 2008 )

Where CaSiO3 ( a pyroxene stuff ) represents a scope of silicate stones

This normally slow procedure is thought to hold been enhanced during Cenozoic clip in the Himalaya part as the actively faulting nature of uplifted terrains Acts of the Apostless to expose great countries of unweathered stone. Further fresh substrate is exposed when weathering merchandises are removed by high strength orographic rainfall, along ill vegetated steep inclines. These factors combine to make big volumes of low surface country silicate dust which acts to increases the rate of hydrolysis reactions during sediment transit, and draws down CO2 ( Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) .

This procedure is so effectual it is considered the chief control on planetary CO2 degrees in some C rhythm theoretical accounts, contrary to the traditionally accepted theoretical account where seafloor distributing associated volcanism controls the atmospheric CO2 concentration ( Berner et al. 1983 ) . The traditional BLAG theoretical account ( named for the initials of the writers ) links the chief atmospheric input flux of CO2 to seafloor spreading ( taking to subduction and out gassing of CO2 ) and the end product flux of CO2 is related to the country of Continental mass available for silicate weathering ( and CO2 drawdown ) ( Berner et al. 1983 ; Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ) . The uplift-erosion CO2 theoretical account elevates the CO2 drawdown by chemical weathering to the chief control on CO2 degrees. Temperature is disregarded in the uplift-erosion theoretical account but plays a cardinal function as a negative feedback mechanism in the BLAG theoretical account. It is suggested that the reaction dynamicss of enduring are increased at higher temperatures associated with an increased nursery consequence due to elevated atmospheric CO2. High rates of reactions increase CO2 remotion, take downing temperatures, traveling the clime to ice-house type conditions. Raymo & A ; Ruddiman ( 1992 ) suggest that it is non temperature but topographic alleviation which encourages high rates of weathering, as high height, aggressive mechanical enduring promotes chemical enduring beyond any addition associated with reaction dynamicss. With the temperature control removed, the uplift-erosion theoretical account of the CO2 rhythm lacks a negative feedback to forestall a runaway chilling and near-depletion of atmospheric CO2. Volcanic outgassing, of import in the BLAG theoretical account offers no plausible mechanism for moving as a negative feedback and the indicant that spreading-ridge activity has been consistent over the past 30 Ma allows it to be discarded as a cardinal variable in the chilling of the Cenozoic clime ( Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ) .

The reading of chilling during the Cenozoic is based on a long-run addition in the 18O/16O ratio ( d18O ) in benthal Foraminifera in calcite ( Fig. 1 ) . The isotopic composing of O in calcite is sensitive to both ice volume and ocean temperature. Precipitation is enriched in the heavier 18O isotope. At times of glaciation, the forming ice is enriched in 18O while saltwater is depleted. An addition over clip in the d18O ratio of saltwater indicates a chilling clime, as observed during the Cenozoic ( Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ) .

Increased silicate enduring through the Cenozoic is inferred by the post-Eocene rise in 87Sr/86Sr ratio in chalky Marine deposits ( Fig. 2 ) . Ruddiman & A ; Raymo ( 1992 ) argue that this rise in the value is due to an addition in volume of Continental weathering of silicate stone nevertheless they noted that Sr is besides derived from the weathering of carbonates, a procedure that does non ensue in a net remotion of CO2 from the ambiance ( Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ) . At the clip of their publication, some workers ( see Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) disagreed and suggested that the addition in 87Sr/86Sr reflects a alteration in beginning part of enduring to sway enriched in 87Sr instead than an addition in volume of enduring. More recent work ( Bickle et al. 2005 ) on riverine fluxes in the Himalya country has sought to set up the comparative part of silicate weathering opposed to carbonate weathering in the Sr part to saltwater. It was calculated that about 50 % of the dissolved Sr flux in the rivers is attributable to silicate weathering and therefore the 87Sr/86Sr ratio can non be taken as a direct index of chemical weathering ( Bickle et al. 2005 ) .

We have discussed how chilling through the Cenozoic has been recorded by an addition in d18O in ice nucleuss and an addition in enduring is inferred from the addition in 87Sr/86Sr ratios of carbonate deposits but it is merely late that Reconstructions of atmospheric CO2 and records of palaeoaltitude have been devised to prove the uplift-erosion hypothesis. Figure 3 summarizes the palaeoelevation of assorted sites in the Himalaya country calculated by assorted workers utilizing stable isotope palaeoaltimetry and biostratigraphy ( Garzione 2008 and mentions in this ) .

The consensus amongst some workers is that cardinal Tibet has been at an lift similar to its modern lift since c. 40-26 Ma proposing epeirogenesis prior to hit ( Garzione 2008 ) . A survey by Dupont-Nivet et Al. ( 2008 ) focused on the disconnected visual aspect of conifer pollen ( in peculiar Picea ) known to tag ice chest climes found in good constrained lacustrine strata deposited between 38.3 Ma and 37.3 Ma. The visual aspect of this cold-climate vegetation prior to the major chilling stage post-EOT indicates uplift to a ice chest clime at this clip in northeast Tibet in a location distal to the collisional forepart ( Garzione 2008 ; Dupont-Nivet et Al. 2008 ) . It is interesting to observe, as highlighted in Figure 2, that the first visual aspect of conifer pollen at 38 Ma coincides with the greatest alteration in the rate of the 87Sr/86Sr jaunt.

Figure 2 besides shows the falling degrees of atmospheric CO2 during the Cenozoic, indicated by multiple placeholders, from around 1400 ppmV at the terminal of the Eocene to every bit low as 200 ppmV during the Miocene ( Garzione 2008 ; Godderis & A ; Donnadieu 2009 ) . During the period 40-25 Ma, the lone placeholder for CO2 degrees comes from alkenones, organic compounds produced by Marine algae. These informations suggest the greatest diminution in CO2 occurred between c. 37 and 25 Ma, closely coinciding with the start of upheaval and addition in enduring ( as inferred from conifer pollen and Sr record severally ) ( Garzione 2008 ) . Despite this uplift-drawdown nexus, CO2 degrees are thought to hold stayed above 180ppmV since the Miocene, with no indicant of an addition in volcanic outgassing. The conditions for CO2 drawdown have persisted indicating that a negative feedback mechanism may hold been invoked, forestalling the complete remotion of CO2 and the oncoming of a snowball Earth ( Pagani et al. 2009 ) . Raymo & A ; Ruddiman ( 1992 ) proposed an instability in the organic C subcycle could move as a negative feedback, where a lessening in organic C entombment would increase the flux of CO2 from the sedimentary C reservoir. This would antagonize much of the CO2 loss via silicate weathering during the last 20 million old ages, but this mechanism is debated ( Raymo & A ; Ruddiman 1992 ; Ruddiman & A ; Burg 1997 ) . More recent work ( Pagani et al. 2009 ) has suggested that as CO2 falls to critically low degrees, forests become starved and are replaced by grasslands. The decrease and alteration in flora compromises the usual sweetening of silicate chemical enduring through stone disintegration by the mechanical actions of roots and the acidification of dirts by root respiration CO2 release ( Pagani et al. 2009 ) . Although discarded by Raymo & A ; Ruddiman ( 1992 ) , the temperature dependance of disintegration reactions could besides move to chair the backdown of CO2 from the ambiance as planetary temperatures fall ( Harris 2006 ) .

The close correspondence of the lessening in CO2A­ and the addition in dO18 alongside the palaeoaltimetry and eroding records point convincingly to an uplifted Himalayan beginning for Cenozoic clime alteration, get downing in earnest at c. 38 Ma. It is besides clear from cool-climate taxa found in strata deposited prior to the major chilling period and found far from the hit zone, that the tableland was well elevated prior to the beginning of the India-Asia hit, widely accepted to hold occurred at 55 Ma. Although alternate day of the months for hit include hit at 70 Ma, of peculiar involvement is work by Aitchison et Al. ( 2007 ) who suggest difficult hit occurred at c. 35 Ma. They ground that the traditional day of the month for hit at 55 Ma records a deceleration of convergence due to India clashing with an intra-oceanic discharge. This proposed later hit would account for the recorded addition in uplift and eroding at this clip. Juvenile hit systems in Taiwan between the Luzon Arc and Eurasia has seen 4000 m of upheaval in 5 Ma old ages and a time-lag of c. 20 Ma between hit and upheaval in a larger collisional system is puzzling.

  • AITCHISON, J.C. , ALI, J.R. & A ; DAVIS, A.M. 2007. When and where did India and Asia collide. Journal of Geophysical Research, 112.
  • BERNER, R.A. , LASAGA, A.C. & A ; GARRELS, R.M. 1983. The carbonate-silicate geochemical rhythm and its consequence on atmospheric C dioxide over the past 100 million old ages. American Journal of Science, 283, 641-683.
  • BICKLE, M.J. , CHAPMAN, H.J. , BUNBURY, J. , HARRIS, N.B.W. , FAIRCHILD, I.J. , AHMAD, T. & A ; POMIES, C. 2005. Relative parts of silicate and carbonate stones to riverine Sr fluxes in the headwaters of the Ganges. Geochimica Et Cosmochimica Acta, 69, 2221-2240.
  • CLIFT, P. D. , HODGES, K. V. , HESLOP, D. , HANNIGAN, R. , VAN LONG, H. & A ; CALVES, G. 2008. Correlation of Himalayan disinterment rates and Asiatic monsoon strength. Nature Geoscience, 1, 875-880.
  • DUPONT-NIVET, G. , HOORN, C. & A ; KONERT, M. 2008. Tibetan uplift prior to the Eocene-Oligocene clime passage: Evidence from pollen analysis of the Xining Basin. Geology, 36, 987-990.
  • DUPONT-NIVET, G. , KRIJGSMAN, W. , LANGEREIS, C. G. , ABELS, H. A. , DAI, S. & A ; FANG, X. 2007. Tibetan tableland aridification linked to planetary chilling at the Eocene-Oligocene passage. Nature, 445, 635-638.
  • GARZIONE, C. N. 2008. Surface upheaval of Tibet and Cenozoic planetary chilling. Geology, 36, 1003-1004.
  • GODDERIS, Y. & A ; DONNADIEU, Y. 2009. Biogeochemistry: Climatic works power. Nature, 460, 40-41.
  • HALL, R. , VAN HATTUM, M. W. A. & A ; SPAKMAN, W. 2008. Impact of India-Asia hit on SE Asia: The record in Borneo. Tectonophysics, 451, 366-389.
  • HARRIS, N. 2006. The lift history of the Tibetan Plateau and its deductions for the Asiatic monsoon. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 241, 4-15.
  • PAGANI, M. , CALDEIRA, K. , BERNER, R. & A ; BEERLING, D. J. 2009. The function of tellurian workss in restricting atmospheric CO2 diminution over the past 24 million old ages. Nature, 460, 85-88.
  • RAYMO, M. E. & A ; RUDDIMAN, W. F. 1992. Tectonic Forcing of Late Cenozoic Climate. Nature, 359, 117-122.
  • ROWLEY, D. B. 1996. Age of induction of hit between India and Asia: A reappraisal of stratigraphic informations. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 145, 1-13.
  • RUDDIMAN, W. & A ; BURG, J. 1997. Tectonic upheaval and clime alteration, Plenum Press New York.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *