Healthcare Practitioners And The Polish Community Social Work Essay

This brooding acquisition log will concentrate on an illustration within the community in respect to interactions by health care professionals with the Polish community. It will get down by puting out current arguments around community coherence and so explicate constructs of favoritism and subjugation to present the relevancy to paramedic pattern. The following subdivision relates these constructs to a pattern illustration. I have chosen to reflect on an illustration within pattern arrangement which sees me called to a Polish Gentleman with reported thorax hurting. The concluding subdivision discusses inclusive patterns to advance equality and sets out future larning

Harmonizing to Flint and Robertson ( 2008 ) Britain is frequently progressively seen as a ‘broken society ‘ . The writers suggest that the societal cement that binds communities together is crumpling. The community we live in should be representative of the people that live within it, they argue, but recognise that how we make a community genuinely cohesive is a complicated affair with respect that people can non be forced to like each other. The impression of ‘community coherence ‘ was coined in the first ‘official ‘ papers was released by local authorities in 2002 giving counsel on community coherence. LGA et Al ( 2002 ) suggested that with sing to community coherence that a cohesive community would expose the undermentioned properties ;

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

Exposing common sense and vision for all within the community.

The diverse backgrounds of persons are valued and positively valued.

Participants from different background have equal chances.

Strong positive relationships at local degree, within the workplace and within schools.

Discrimination can be an equivocal term. Hellman ( 2008 ) suggests that favoritism as a term can be understood in one of two ways, either descriptive or moralized. Descriptive favoritism can be understood as pulling a differentiation on the footing of a trait being present or absent. On the other manus moralized favoritism can be understood as pulling differentiations that are incorrect.

Prejudice and favoritism can happen on many degrees both in the community and on a wider graduated table. The grounds for bias and prejudiced behavior should be considered and the underpinning grounds for it address to genuinely be able to extinguish favoritism ( Oskamp, 2000 ) . Such behavior can be considered oppressive and those enduring favoritism can be under advantaged in cardinal countries of lodging, employment, schooling and entree to healthcare and wellness resources. Discrimination displayed within this brooding acquisition log are really similar to the considerations of Ameli, Merali & A ; Elahi ( 2004 ) who suggest that favoritism in the chief is frequently elusive frequently deducing from ignorance of deficiency of consideration for others feelings.

Young ( 2000 ) defines subjugation through the ‘Five Faces of Oppression ‘ theoretical account in which it considers the five types of subjugation persons can confront in society. The five phases being Exploitation, Marginalisation, Powerlessness, Cultural Imperialism and Violence. Young ( 2000 ) goes farther to specify subjugation as one societal group whether wittingly or unconsciously exploits another societal group for its ain benefit. Each country of the five faces of subjugation can be ascertained as ;

Exploitation, can be understood by the general experiences within the work topographic point. Exploitation is frequently experient and observed in workers runing in what is seen as basic or unskilled work. Young ( 2000 ) goes farther to propose that development is associated with the allocating of occupations and the associated wagess which are determined by the persons place in society.

Marginalization, Is a serious issue which can affect disaffection and isolation towards an person. This can hold many knock on effects which frequently sees the person happening it difficult to incorporate. Independent Communications Network Ltd ( 2002 ) states that ‘Marginalisation comes up when you have a set of regulations, either puting out intentionally to favor person and disadvantage another ‘

Powerlessness, is concerned with persons who possibly lack authorization and the feeling of ego regulation and independency. Sweetman ( 2004 ) interestingly suggests that impotence can be linked with exclusion where persons are prevented from having equal determination devising abilities and finally exerting their human rights and freedoms.

Cultural Imperialism, can be implied when the person is seen as a separate and in some manner different to the ruling group. Tomlinson ( 1991 ) suggests that ‘cultural imperialism ‘ does non hold a peculiarly long history and believe is emerged in the 1960 ‘s along with other extremist unfavorable judgments.

Violence, is based on an person ‘s fright or existent experience of force. Violence can be displayed in a figure of ways both physically and by psychological methods. The effects of force restrict the motion of the person in society as they live in fright.

Another cardinal position point is Hardiman and Jackson ( 1997 ) Social Oppression Matrix. This can be broken down in a figure of cardinal countries to give a good rounded apprehension of subjugation and the assorted signifiers it takes. The matrix suggests that subjugation on the one manus can be formed from the Individual where thoughts and in peculiar believes and attitudes displayed can take to subjugation by the person. On the other manus Institutional subjugation occurs when the attitudes and behaviors can be passed down through coevalss by establishments such as educational constitutions or spiritual administrations.

Hardiman and Jackson ( 1997 ) besides suggest that subjugation can be displayed at society/cultural degree for illustration through deficiency of statute law whereby handicapped people are discriminated once more. A farther illustration of this could be a deaf individual who does non hear an hearable fire dismay.

Hardiman and Jackson ( 1997 ) travel further to propose that favoritism can attest itself in a figure of ways through cardinal attitudes and behavior or via both witting and unconscious Acts of the Apostless. By witting we mean being intentionally oppressive and discriminatory and by unconscious we mean that the individual/ establishment or society is non cognizant that what is being done is aching or piquing. The Social Oppression Matrix can besides be used in a opposite mode to look at rectifying jobs by looking back through the matrix. For illustration how might the behavior of an individual/ establishment alteration and how can attitudes and behaviours be changed or removed for the good of others.

My engagement in the taught Sessionss within the Living and working in a Diverse World faculty has allowed me to develop new thoughts. The class has allowed me to reflect and include constructs of diverseness within my portfolio contemplations. This ensures I am run intoing the demands of my professional organic structure and enhances me as a practician. This support the positions of Ely & A ; Scott ( 2007 ) who suggests a portfolio is a systematic, purposeful and meaningful aggregation of a pupil ‘s work in one or more capable countries. Areas covered include Ageism, Equality, Class and Disability and have allowed me to dispute pre conceived thoughts that I had before get downing the faculty. The Sessionss are straight relevant to my function as a Student Paramedic whereby I must be able to run into the demands and understand the diverse civilization that the community is made up of. I have carried out a great trade of contemplation with Diversity in head and in peculiar the workshops have changed my apprehension and interaction with minority groups. The talks and workshops have had a large impact within my personal life and I am tolerant and more cognizant of diverseness and its topographic point in society. Interestingly Johns ( 2000 ) identifies certain qualities of head that I as a practician am more cognizant of. The qualities harmonizing to the writer are all necessary for contemplation including openness, wonder, unruliness or committedness, and intelligence.

In all instances of contemplation I complete I use the Gibbs ( 1998 ) contemplation rhythm. The grounds for utilizing this brooding rhythm is that it allows the instance to be analysed with all elements considered including ethical issues. It besides allows an chance to propose alterations that would do go toing such incidents better in the hereafter. The rhythm follows keys countries of an event inquiring the reflector to reply inquiries on, a description of the event? , Thoughts and feelings? , Period of Analysis? , Conclusion? , eventually a re-action program covering countries of betterment. Moonie & A ; Spencer-Perkins ( 2004 ) interestingly defines contemplation as underpinning the believing elements of plants that are completed in order a worker is able to develop accomplishments.

I understand that as a pupil paramedic and while heading towards the position of Graduate Paramedic I am responsible for exposing thoughts and a professional attitude. I am cognizant of how my behavior can be observed and how my interactions via the Social Oppression Matrix can be observed. Be it via witting idea for illustration devising premises about a group or via unconscious idea and non cognizing that the manner I interact with some patient can take into consequence my diverse ideas and experiences ( Shevrin, 1995 ) .

I was called to a 64 twelvemonth old Polish male with reported thorax hurting whilst crewing an ambulance auto along with my wise man. Prior to go toing I had ideas of perchance the patient cachexia clip, these ideas were based on interactions with other members of the Polish community who had called with thorax hurting in the yesteryear with the mentality to utilize the ambulance as a cab merely to acquire to hospital and run from the dorsum.

On reaching I was met outside by members of the patient ‘s household they were shouting at me in Polish. I could non understand what they were stating to me nevertheless one was drawing at my manus this left me experiencing threatened and sing if constabularies were required, I asked them to “ stand back ” . The visual aspect of the household members being good built males all with shaved caput and one keeping a can of beer lead me towards this threatened province. The household besides appeared to be angry and although I could non do out the linguistic communication I felt they were cussing me.

I went to the dorsum of the auto and selected cardinal equipment that would be used in a patient with thorax hurting. On acquiring into the house I noticed it to be in bad province of frock, I besides noticed hemorrhoids of paperwork associating to occupation searchers allowance littering the floor. There were about two bottles of empty vodka and 16 empty Sns of intoxicant on the floor.

On acquiring to the patient side I could see he appeared to be in hurting, a male ( a friend within the house ) who could talk English said to me ‘I cognize you do n’t wish us but delight aid him ‘ at this point I replied “ we will make everything we can ” . This is a idea that has stuck with me of all time since. I hence completed full observations and completed a tracing of the patient ‘s bosom. It was clear from this trial that the male was enduring from a myocardial infarction. A short period subsequently the patient went into a province of cardiac apprehension and a full resuscitative protocol was initiated. After a period the patient was transferred to Accident and Emergency nevertheless died a short clip subsequently. We had given 100 % intervention to this patient nevertheless on decision and on cleaning up our equipment the patient ‘s household said ‘he did n’t stand a opportunity he is Polish ‘ . I felt that a challenge should be initiated and told the household “ I ‘m really regretful you feel this manner and we are regretful for your loss. We did everything we could for him both here and at the infirmary ” . I did non experience the state of affairs warranted me giving my point of view owing to the feelings of the household and the heartache they were experiencing.

After the event I had serious consideration to the statement made by the household. I have ever held pre-conceived thoughts about the Polish Community with my local town. I had besides ne’er challenged ideas of other colleges who commented on my instance ‘probably the drink ‘ , ‘makes a alteration from them blowing clip ‘ these type of remarks have become acceptable within the community. These remarks fit with Young ( 2000 ) thoughts of cultural imperialism in that the Polish community are seen as separate in some manner to us in this instance of the dominant group. Within the wider community I have heard many remarks sing Polish Nationals including, ‘they take out occupations ‘ , ‘are the root cause of problem ‘ , ‘if they are in England they should talk English ‘ . It seems that these thoughts and remarks are non defined as violative or racialist and possibly this is born out of ignorance or a feeling of being threatened. As a healthcare professional I understand that comments in relation to racism, gender and disablement are violative nevertheless remarks made about this sector of the community seem to travel by undisputed. So are these remarks deemed to be racist? Or are they merely a look of sentiment.

Meehen ( 2007 ) defined racism as ;

“ The committee proposed to specify ‘racism and xenophobia ‘ as ‘the belief in race, coloring material, descent, faith or belief, national or cultural beginning as a factor finding antipathy to single or group ”

Corlett ( 2003 ) goes farther to propose racism can be divided in to both higher and lower order racism. Lower order racism being keeping a bias and position and know aparting on the footing of this in an unwilling signifier. Higher order racism involves intentionally utilizing the bias and favoritism in an active signifier. This links really much with the Social Oppression Matrix by Hardiman and Jackson ( 1997 ) .

This incident has brought about a great trade of contemplation, the primary ground for this is to guarantee should I see a Polish household in the hereafter I am better equipt to run into the demands of the community.

A big figure of Polish subjects migrated to the United Kingdom since 2004 after the expansion of the European Union. There has been a dominant rise from Polish communities to the United Kingdom which has been most seeable in the public country. Since 2004 it is estimated that 540,000 Polish citizens are working within the United Kingdom Labour Market. ( Burrell, 2009 ) . Initially a big growing in immigrant labor was seen in London which has continued to lift. Importantly the metropolis is now wholly dependent on immigrant labor in order to map ( Srivastava, 2007 ) .

On contemplation it is of import to see the grounds for my actions and feelings in relation to this event. Prior to this event Polish subjects may hold been seen as being exploited frequently than non seen in lower paid work such as factory employment. Polish subjects are frequently make fulling spreads in the labor market that others will non make full. Chen, Vanek & A ; Carr ( 2004 ) suggests that Migrant workers should hold appropriate entree to exigency wellness attention. Further to this there is a deficiency of acknowledgment of infinite migrator workers which mean they can non prosecute in civic and societal life within their new communities.

It is besides of import to see the manner in which the patient and their household may hold felt in this instance. Based on the actions and spoken words of this group it was evident they may hold felt marginalised by myself. They may hold felt as If I was non pressing in my attack to their place reference.

Developing this contemplation further and looking at impotence as a topic I feel this was a chief country of the this incident. The household may hold perceived they lacked material authorization and had negative feelings about the intervention they may have from the ambulance service.

On contemplation I feel my attitude premises and experiencing taking up to and during the incident may give rise to issues of ‘Cultural Imperialism ‘ in that the patients household may hold felt different to the ruling group in this instance myself as the healthcare professional. Young ( 2000 ) suggests that those dominated undergo a self-contradictory subjugation in that they undergo a procedure whereby they are stereotyped every bit good as being rendered unseeable.

To analyze my feelings nearing the incident the feelings of this being ‘another Polish member with thorax hurting ‘ is linked with stereotyped positions. Hardiman and Jackson ( 1997 ) societal subjugation matrix suggests that these experiencing on an single degree are likely to be unconscious ideas. After all I would non deliberately set about upsetting person or exposing these attitudes and feelings in forepart of the patients or household. On nearing the reference and on acquiring inside and seeing stuffs such as occupation searchers paperwork and alcohol I was phased. This supported my stereotype of Polish national in that in the bulk do non work and are to a great extent drink dependent. Brief ( 2004 ) suggests stereotypes frequently differentiate “ us ” from “ them ” and this is something that I have applied subconsciously, by organizing sentiments and listening to general remarks from other members of society. Issues arise from pigeonholing in that frequently positions are inaccurate and frequently ignorance is the chief factor in drama. The intoxicant Sns and paperwork are ocular marks along with non understanding the linguistic communication allowed be to go fearful of force. It was evident that I was sing the intoxicant usage as a signifier of cultural alcohol addiction.

There are linked considerations with Cultural Competence being called into inquiry within this contemplation. Cultural Competence is defined by Srivastava ( 2007 ) as ;

Ability of wellness attention professionals to use cognition and skill suitably in interactions with client.

This besides bring about feelings personally in that there were barriers in this incident that impacted on cultural competent attention in that ;

There was a distinguishable deficiency of diverseness both personally and from the leading and work force within the ambulance service.

There was hapless communicating between myself as a supplier of attention and the terminal user including patients of different race or cultural backgrounds.

These positions are peculiarly evident and on contemplation I can place that there is a deficiency of diverseness on both an single degree and on a institutional degree. Hardiman and Jackson ( 1997 ) Social Oppression Matrix look at different point of views in relation to subjugation. I can associate cardinal countries of my feelings during this incident to the matrix on both the Individual, Institution and Society.

As an person I feel my unconscious feeling are demonstrated though the formed stereotypes and feelings towards intoxicant and general exposure. Attitudes displayed are non altered and equal attention is given to every patient. However behavior may be displayed consciously possibly by non seeking to explicate or battle the linguistic communication barriers.

On an institutional degree there is a distinguishable deficiency of diverseness or way in relation to different groups that make up the community. The ambulance service in the hereafter needs to guarantee for illustration that communicating is made more simple with linguistic communication cue cards. I feel they will besides necessitate to put in more diverseness preparation to guarantee the stereotypes are shown to be baseless. The establishment is guilty in the witting signifier as it is non in touch with the community it serves.

In relation to society their demands to be farther integrating so that any concerns are explored. At present there are witting attitudes and behaviors displayed in countries such as lodging and employment. In the future incidents or interactions diverseness and inclusive practise demands to be considered. Inclusive practise should affect a bundle of attention and guarantee all elements of health care are brought together. This is an umbrella attack including quality attention, regard for the individual and state of affairs every bit good as a diverse apprehension of civilization, faith and equality. To be a more inclusive practician I have ensured I take the duty to larn about the civilizations around me including:

Basic Knowledge on the civilizations that make up my community.

Basic apprehension of faith.

Basford & A ; Slevin ( 2008 ) suggest that the small things can do a state of affairs a good 1. Small nominal gestures of good being, understanding and acknowledgment can take to a more positive result. To contrast spiritual and cultural errors can take to offence and straiten.

Contemplation is a cardinal portion of every health care practician ‘s development and this procedure including attending at diverseness session has allowed me to measure my practise. I am more culturally cognizant of how my ideas, feelings and behaviors affect interactions with communities. It has allowed me to develop both assurance and most significantly understanding in order to dispute in appropriate comments. I will take frontward both this brooding piece and attending at Diversity workshops frontward and portion my experiences with crew members, household and other cardinal groups.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *